News or niche media site · Version 1.0
Comment policy
this site
A written comment policy for this site: who moderates, what is published, how fast held comments are reviewed, and what happens when a thread turns hostile.
Who moderates
- Moderation lead. Sets this policy, owns the queue's response times, and reports on moderation every month for this site.
- Moderators. Approve, reject, mark spam, and escalate. Two moderators cover a busy thread so no single person decides alone.
Purpose and scope
- This policy explains how this site reviews, publishes, and removes comments. It applies to every comment box on the site, including articles, guides, and reference pages.
- We host comments to make the work more useful to readers, not to maximize engagement metrics. Criticism of this site is allowed. Abuse of other readers is not.
- This is a working document for moderators and a public statement for readers. It is not legal advice, and it does not replace the law or a platform’s terms.
What we publish
- We publish first-hand experience, questions, corrections, and disagreement with the article. A comment does not need to agree with us to stay up.
- We publish relevant links when they add evidence or context to the thread. We remove undisclosed promotion, affiliate links, and the same comment repeated across threads.
- We do not publish harassment, threats, hate speech, targeted abuse, doxxing, impersonation, spam, deliberate disruption, or content that breaks the law or a court order.
- We remove a comment for breaking one of those rules, not because it is critical. When a comment is removed, the moderator records which rule applied.
How comments are reviewed
- A first-time commenter's comment is held for review before it publishes. Once someone has an approved comment and no recent removals, later comments publish immediately and are screened by the spam filter.
- Automated screening runs before the queue. It flags likely spam and holds it; it does not make the final decision on a borderline comment.
- Moderators may approve or reject from email or Slack. The decision is recorded in the dashboard with the moderator’s name and the time.
- No moderator acts on a thread they are personally involved in. It goes to another moderator.
When a thread turns hostile
Start with the lightest step that settles the thread. A hold on one thread is reversible; a ban is not, so it comes later.
- Hold new comments for review on that thread only. Existing comments stay visible and the rest of the site is unaffected.
- Remove the comment that broke the policy and record which rule it broke.
- Lock the thread if the discussion cannot continue without abuse. A lock stops new comments; it does not delete the discussion.
- Ban the commenter from commenting on this site. A ban applies to one site, never to every site on the platform.
- Record the decision — the comment, the rule, the moderator, and the time — and tell the moderation lead.
Response times
- We aim to review held comments within four business hours during coverage. Reports of threats, doxxing, or illegal content are handled within one hour when a moderator is on shift.
- These are targets, not guarantees. If the queue is longer than usual, we say so in the thread rather than leave readers guessing.
Bans and appeals
- A ban applies to one site, not to every site on the platform.
- A reader can appeal a decision by contacting the moderation contact published on the site. Include the comment and the thread.
- One person who did not make the original decision reviews the appeal.
- If we got it wrong, we restore the comment and say so in the thread.
Privacy and data
- We collect the minimum needed to publish and moderate a comment: display name, comment text, timestamp, and the sign-in identity the reader chose.
- We do not sell comment data or use it for advertising.
- We keep moderation records for 12 months, then delete them unless a legal hold applies.
- A reader can ask for a copy or deletion of their comment data by contacting the moderation contact published on the site.
Reviewing this policy
- The moderation lead reviews this policy every six months and after any serious incident.
- Changes are published on this page with the date. Moderators are briefed before a change takes effect.
- The moderation log is reviewed monthly for patterns: which rules fire, which threads need a second moderator, and whether the response times are realistic.
Contact
the moderation contact published on the site
Questions, reports, and appeals. For urgent safety issues, use the subject line URGENT.
Draft generated with the free EchoThread comment moderation policy generator. Edit it to match your site, publish it, and review it every six months.